What is the most important point in choosing a company to invest in in the market?
Regarding this issue, a senior I knew before taught me that it was a “person”, that is, the manager of that company.
I once believed in this, but the facts that I saw later seemed to show more and more that this method of judgment was unreliable. Especially for ordinary investors.
The unreliable part is that it is more difficult to understand a company manager than people can afford. It may even be impossible.
Among the obstacles, the most difficult one is the media.
Those corporate leaders, especially those of larger-scale listed companies, have shown their images in the media long ago by the company’s public relations department, outsourced PR, and financial reporters’ cognitive errors.
The gap between the character reports of financial media (except CBN, cough cough) and the true status of the reported person is probably larger than the gap between the vibrato filter and the actual appearance of the anchor. Ordinary investors want to know what the leadership and management capabilities of a company are, and there is basically no effective channel.
Taking a step back, even if an investor can grasp the real work performance of business leaders, can they predict their ability to practice through these performances?
At the beginning of the 20th century, Sigmund Freud and his disciples claimed to be able to do similar things, but the end result showed that this was a hoax or a misunderstanding. What’s more, probably no one has the opportunity to ask the CEO of a company to sit comfortably on a recliner and then dangle a pocket watch in front of him.
For ordinary people, don’t try to figure out the virtues of the management of listed companies. Your girlfriend was supposed to go to dinner together after get off work, but suddenly sent a WeChat message saying “a little tired”-what do you mean by that?
Taking a step back, it is very likely that there is no direct linear relationship between the management’s ability to perform and the company’s operating conditions-this is the most deadly point for investors who “choose knights, don’t choose horses”, because it makes all relevant The manager’s analysis seemed to be in vain.
Let me give you an example.
One A-share listed company has changed four chairmanships within four years. And one of these four terms was sentenced to life for breaking the law; the other two had never been in contact with the company’s main business before becoming the head of the company. Does it sound like this company can still want it?
However, the facts may be beyond your expectations. If an investor bought the company’s stock during such a chaotic period, that is, when it changed its chairman for the first time, and held it until the time it just changed its chairman, then his investment income would reach 350%. The chemical yield rate is 43%. This result can probably outperform all public fund managers in China.
Perhaps, as value investors, we should not only focus on stock prices. So how is the company’s operations? Its net profit growth rate in the last 4 years is close to 170%, and its annual growth rate is 28%. This performance is excellent enough in A-shares.
This company is real, it is the king of A stock market value-Kweichow Moutai.
Of course, we cannot use the example of Kweichow Moutai to assert that a company’s operating status has nothing to do with the manager’s ability to perform, or to exaggerately believe that the worse the manager, the better the company’s operations-we can’t just look at the problem either one or the other. But it is certain that the degree of correlation between the company’s operating level and the management’s ability to perform is lower than most people think, and much lower.
Choosing a good “person” and reinvesting is simply impossible.
The reason for this low correlation should be that the system has a diluting effect on personal influence, especially in mature modern enterprises, the diluting effect is more and more obvious.
Then, with regard to the selection of “people” and then investing in a company, if you encounter embarrassment at the level of stock selection, will investors adopt it in the selection of funds with good results?
Although the public opinion propaganda work of fund companies seems to be repeated in various gestures “our fund managers have a good historical performance”-a profession without tension-the truth is still regrettable: select outstanding fund managers and buy the products they manage , This road to wealth still has the problem of too high identification cost and invalid identification.
How can investors single out the best performers from the many funds? The basis is basically the historical performance of fund managers given by the fund company. Judging from the transcripts given by the fund company, there are indeed fund managers with surprisingly high long-term investment performance. But don’t be too happy. Generally speaking, the number of funds managed by a gold fund manager alone is more than the number of girls that the most scumbag loves at the same time. When the company is marketing him, it only selects the best returns among its managed funds to show investors. Calculated in this way, their grades are of course good.
The prominent example here is Yi Fangda’s Zhang ×. The 5-year annualized return of an A-share stock fund managed by Zhang Gushen is 19%. This is a pretty good result. But at the same time, the annualized return of the fund he manages to invest in the Asia-Pacific market is only 5.3%, which is far below the reference index.
My 4-year-old daughter’s favorite game is to compare the draws with me. She always wins. The reason is that I can only draw a card once, and she can draw several times until her card is bigger than me-it seems that this little villain has the potential to engage in fund promotion work.
Even if you buy a product of a very good fund manager, and the guy’s historical performance is objective, the end of the investor may not be very good. The reason is that it is difficult for people to distinguish the difference between luck and long-term investment ability.
Let me give you another example and you will understand what I mean.
Manager Liu×Song, the fund he manages won the champion of investment income in 2019. In 2020 and 2021, Liu Gushen’s results are also quite outstanding. What are you doing in a daze, buy it?
Wait a minute. If an investor who likes to lift the bar stretches the timeline a little longer, he will find something surprising. Between 2015 and 2017, the total investment yields of the two funds managed by Liu Gushen were -49.5% and -43.5%, respectively-this level of loss is about the same as the efficiency of throwing banknotes directly into the toilet.
Liu Gushen worked in two fund companies around 2018. The difference in the returns of the funds under his management is so large that it may be related to the degree of support by the fund companies for his work. But it is more likely that things like luck have had different effects on his more aggressive investment methods. Therefore, if investors buy such funds, a serious problem they will face is whether they will repeat the fortune from 2015 to 2017 or the fortune from 2019 to 2021—it is very likely that Liu Gu Shen himself will repeat his fortune from 2015 to 2017. do not know either.
If you don’t mind, I want to mention my daughter again.
I bought her a set of DC hero figures. She will assume that the dolls will play treasure hunts with her as independent players. This kind of treasure hunt game is based entirely on luck and throwing dice. When the Flash defeated Superman and many other heroes 3 times in 4 games, and finally won the treasure, an interesting phenomenon appeared. In future treasure hunt games, if the Flash participates, my daughter will cheat for the Flash and deliberately let him win. This is because she thinks the Flash is the best treasure hunting superhero and he should win.
As I said at the beginning, my daughter is only 4 years old. The cognitive bias she embodies is probably human nature. People need to find patterns in a disorderly world, such as something delicious, a safer place, or a superhero who is good at winning treasure hunts. Even if some of these laws are prejudices, they are willing or required to do so, because such recognition will make people feel at ease.
When many people are looking for companies and funds worth investing in, they attribute the problem to finding outstanding corporate managers and fund managers. This complex is probably the same as my daughter’s belief that the Flash is more likely to hunt for treasure. Investors probably have an anti-logic. If a player has achieved good results in all three games, then he is the Flash.
I even think that this kind of social and psychological phenomenon can be extended to a broader level, and the era when great people and heroes are more likely to appear is an era when people are confused.
The heroism complex is probably an illusion of random misjudgment.

Comments are closed