Beethoven’s “Island” Philosophy in the Music

1. Challenge: Monopolize the complete works of Beethoven’s 32 piano sonatas

  Milan Kundera once described the late style of Beethoven’s music, “He has reached the pinnacle of art: sonatas and quartets are different from any other composer. Due to their structural complexity, they are far away from classicism, and at the same time they are not Therefore, he is close to the ingenuity of the young romantic composers: in the evolution of music, he has embarked on a road that no one follows… His free work in his twilight years is a miracle, an island.” .
  On the evening of June 19, 2021, Cao Peng, a young pianist studying in Germany from Xi’an Conservatory of Music, performed a Beethoven Piano Sonata concert at the Xi’an Concert Hall in Qujiang, Xi’an. The repertoires are Beethoven’s Piano Sonata No. 1 in F minor (Work 2), Piano Sonata No. 7 in D Major (Work 10) and Piano Sonata No. 29 in B-flat Major (Work 106). Counting the five works he performed in March this year, such as “Piano Sonata No. 8 in C Minor” (Operation 13) and “Piano Sonata No. 28 in A Major” (Operation 101), this is his second Beethoven performance this year. The piano sonata concert is also the fifth concert of his series of Beethoven piano sonatas since the gradual recovery of live concerts in the middle of last year.
  In the past 2020, it is undoubtedly a “big year” to commemorate the birth of Beethoven, the “Le Saint”, and concerts of Beethoven’s works worldwide are showing a blowout trend. But in my impression, it’s rare to see Beethoven’s complete 32 piano sonatas performed by piano soloists “on their own”; only for domestic performers, such a challenging solo concert is even more of a challenge. There are only a handful of them.

  So, what does it mean for us to listen to all of Beethoven’s piano sonatas?
  ”Integrating classical masterpieces and pioneering romance.” People generally use this language to evaluate Beethoven. This is not only because his works have been in the “crown” position of Western music for more than 300 years; more importantly, in In the history of music, Beethoven is indeed irreplaceable. Few people can live in the two important art history periods of “classical” and “romantic” at the same time with a glorious posture like him. In other words, when he used his creation to promote the development of classical music to its peak, he opened up a new era of music art history with his own innovation and breakthrough: romantic music. As a result, some people commented on Beethoven, who was already one of the three masters of the Vienna classical music school, “The whole era of romanticism traveled along the channel he had dug.”
  At the same time, for Beethoven, piano sonatas and symphonies occupies a unique and special place in his music works of many genres. In particular, his piano sonatas are the perfect fusion of the composer’s personal will and his self-understanding of the changing times and social innovation. Therefore, in a sense, listening to all Beethoven’s piano sonatas in a complete and systematic manner can be called a spiritual tour of the history of Western classical music.
  As a performer, the complete presentation of Beethoven’s piano sonatas in seven concerts is also a magnificent but arduous trek. And as the fifth of them, it is just at the critical moment in the middle of the entire series of performances, just like the critical moment in the marathon that is about to break through the physical limits of runners. And the most eye-catching and anticipated thing in this concert is “Work 106”, which is known as the “Ninth Symphony” in the piano sonata. Various factors make the concert of the day particularly interesting.
  In the first half, the two works “Piano Sonata No. 1 in F Minor” and “Piano Sonata No. 7 in D Major” are familiar to most listeners, and they are also the works with a higher performance rate in Beethoven’s piano sonatas. Compared to other well-known works of composers such as “sorrow”, “passion” and “tempest”, these two works seem to lack some dazzling auras. At the concert, Cao Peng showed a very unusual restraint and calm in his performance. Especially for the first “F minor”, he almost played the whole song in an upright posture like a statue, but his fingertips showed the colorful sound color without reservation. It can be said that as a performer, he treats the two works with a kind of internal power that completely “controls” the works, which is as easy as searching for something. This also makes the whole work show precise and delicate timbre changes, as well as an excellent texture that is relaxed but not lacking in tenacity. Under Cao Peng’s calm and composed performance, every note seemed to be “paved” just right. In the second work “Piano Sonata No. 7 in D Major,” especially certain phrases in the third movement, as Beethoven once described the song, “with subtle changes in light and shadows Portray”. Cao Peng’s interpretation also shows as much as possible agility full of life, showing the performer’s precise grasp of the composer and the style of the work.
2. “Island”: Philosophy in the Musical Age

  After the “warm-up” of the works in the first half of the concert, the audience finally ushered in the second half of the “Piano Sonata No. 29 in B flat major”. For many listeners, it is more than listening to music. An inquiring about the inner world of Le Saint Beethoven and a philosophical journey of thought.
  This song “Work 106” was created between 1817 and 1818. At this time, the composer had just gone through several years of creative silence, and his deafness became more serious and eventually he was almost deaf. In addition, he had several “failure” experiences in love and his family conflicts fighting for custody of his nephew Carl… Intertwined with multiple personal physical and mental difficulties, it can be described as a low ebb in Beethoven’s life and creation. But at the same time, this is an extremely unusual time node, because in the ten years from the composition of the song to the death of the composer, it is Beethoven’s truly brilliant “late style” that everyone talks about-for the history of music. In terms of this, this is a milestone in the final establishment and finalization of the composer’s style; and personally, this is also the key moment when Beethoven has gradually become the “temple” sequence from a composer with a complicated personality. Therefore, it can be said that “Piano Sonata No. 29 in B flat major” is not only the concluding remarks of the classical era, but also the opening words of the romantic era. It has the same extraordinary significance for music history and composers.

  The performance time and volume of this work greatly surpassed the general keyboard sonata. We can also regard this work as the composer forcing a certain symphonic thinking into the structure of a piano sonata. This kind of treatment is in line with the sturdy and even arrogant image of the “Le Saint” as always. I think this should be something deliberately done by the composer. Because, at the same time as the creation of “Piano Sonata No. 29 in B flat major”, Beethoven was also conceiving the “Ninth Symphony”. In a sense, “Work 106” is more like Beethoven’s first thought and mental preparation for the creation of “Beijing Nine”

  Especially as the beginning of Beethoven’s last ten years of brilliant creation, this work not only retains many basic elements of classical music, but also breaks through and develops many classical stereotypes, and finally predicts romantic music elements. Generally show the world.
  For a good performance in a piano concert, the performer should be able to clearly explain every note, and show the composer’s rich musical thoughts through the rich changes of timbre. Furthermore, each phrase in the work also has a clear direction, and through the mutual inclination and mutual construction of the phrase and the phrase, it ultimately points to the path and direction the composer wants to express.
  Before the performance, Cao Peng even spent a few minutes telling the audience about his mental journey in preparing this work. He regretted and blamed himself for not being able to perform memorization. He was also worried that certain passages in the work would It makes people “get lost while listening”, which creates a lot of confusion in their practice and preparation. In the performance of the day, whether it is the timbre processing of details or the directivity presented by the “phrases” that exist in the structure of the work, Cao Peng’s performance has reached an impeccable situation. He treated the works in a calm and unhurried manner, so that even though he actually played 46 minutes on the spot, many listeners did not feel that it was long. On the contrary, there was a sense of compactness, coherence and unfinished intentions. It was really not easy!
  It is still returning to this unparalleled work. The reason why people call it the “Ninth Symphony” in piano works is nothing more than for several reasons: First, it is the extraordinary scale in the piano sonata. It is not a small challenge for both the performer and the audience; more importantly, if the work is regarded as a symphony, the most obvious reason may be the first and fourth movements of the work. Whether it is the full and gorgeous chord connection at the beginning of the first movement, or the more than ten-minute fugue passage in the fourth movement, they have gone beyond ordinary piano thinking and are more symphonic. When I listen to many excellent classical music works, I often pay special attention to the “fugue” of the works. In my opinion, good fugue paragraphs-the counterpoint of different levels of sound presented in accordance with special rules, is an important means to introduce the temperament of musical works into depth; at the same time, wonderful fugue paragraphs will also make the whole work Be given more connotation and ideology. And this brings great challenges to performance: On the one hand, the performer should try to present a musical image in line with the piano’s own temperament on the piano as a solo instrument, but at the same time, the composer must be turned into a symphony. Hearing and musical imagination-whether it is the gradation of the orchestra’s timbre or the dramatic tension imparted by the intensity-to be presented in a piano as properly as possible, it is almost a “paradox” dilemma Situation. This requires the performer to dig from the inside of the work and give a very clear and accurate explanation of the phrase presentation of the work. In other words, the performer needs to face the work with an uncompromising attitude and an inner determination that is neither humble nor overbearing. Any trace of ambiguity, hesitation, and deviation in the understanding of music will destroy the complete presentation of the work.
  If some of Beethoven’s symphonies are compared to public declarations to society, then the piano sonatas are more like his personal diary—the adagios in it are more similar to the composer’s private “inner confession”, the first part of this work. 2. The third movement is the deep inner return of the composer. Although after the performance, Cao Peng ridiculed himself and said that the audience could “sleep” in the slightly dull three movements, but I saw it clearly at the concert, and even some audience members quietly wiped the corners of their eyes while listening. Tears. During the entire concert that day, almost all the audience were attracted by the performer’s piano and listened quietly, so that during the whole breath-holding live performance, the piano boy next to the performer who was in charge of flipping through the music said The slight sound of the music is a kind of interference to the sound field of the performance.
  The challenge brought by this work to the performers even made Charles Rosen have to sigh with emotion that “willingly and fiercely are unheard of in music”. Beethoven in the late style is often referred to as an “island”-he is alone, long and independent, different from anyone, even “breaking” from his own past. But the composer’s heart at this time is obsessed with Kant’s “starry sky” philosophy. In my opinion, this series of factors related to Beethoven’s self-isolation may be the reason why Cao Peng felt confused when he first faced this work. We can think that this piece is too difficult, complicated, and even ambiguous or mysterious, but it is precisely a declaration of the times: the composer has finally made full preparations after careful consideration and the hesitation and struggle that every mortal has had. He took up the courage to challenge the music road of the new era to reach the top, and the romanticism of the entire 19th century was precisely in the lead of Beethoven. At the same time, in the concert that night, the audience also heard a young performer who submitted a perfect interpretation to the audience after experiencing intense arguments and choices with himself.
3. Expectation: a “unique” pianist

  As a performer, if there is no independent thought that conforms to the self-disposition and music logic, it may be no different from a “machine” with flexible fingers. While listening to Cao Peng’s concert, I even suggested to my familiar friends with my strong subjective will to read Cao Peng’s text about music. A senior music editor replied to me after reading the music essays written by Cao Peng, “The words written by performers are sometimes unique.” Because behind his vivid words, you can not only experience a young pianist’s unique understanding of his interpretation of the musical works and his composer, but also feel his identity as a “performer”. Special thinking.

  In fact, as far as concert performance is concerned, a really good performance does not require the performer to worship the composer as a failure, nor is it bluffing or arrogance to cover up lack of self-confidence. A good performer should have inner peace, respect and rational enthusiasm, and have a knee-jerk conversation with the composer that spans time and space.
  ”Almost every three months, I will prepare a set of Beethoven sonatas and communicate with the audience at the concert.” Cao Peng told the audience after the performance. This is not only his communication and interaction with the audience, but also A performer’s pursuit and self-appointment for his own career and musical beliefs. In September and December this year, he will also present ten other piano sonatas of Beethoven in two concerts in Xi’an. These will also be the last two final performances of the entire Beethoven sonata series, including “Farewell “(Work 81a) also has “passion” (Work 57).
  In addition to self-discipline in the pursuit of art, Cao Peng also has many unconventional ideas about his concerts. He believes that if only compliedly playing the works of those composers in history, there will be much less fun and even meaning of the profession as a “pianist”. Therefore, in the return to the concert that day, he also played two pieces of his own improvisation, which made the concert quite innovative-this is also another way to “challenge” himself. All these also give us more reasons to look forward to. In the next performance, Cao Peng will join hands with “Beethoven” to present more exciting sound and meaningful and challenging philosophies to the audience.

Tags:

Comments are closed