Recently, Archaeology, the world’s most authoritative academic archaeological journal, named the “Top 10 Archaeological Discoveries in the World” for 2021. The “Lost City of Gold” in Egypt – the ancient city of Aten in Luxor, southern Egypt – was ranked No. 1 on the list, and in second place were the ancient human hand and footprints discovered by Chinese scholar Zhang Dian, a professor at Guangzhou University, and others at Qiusang Hot Spring in Tibet, which is also the earliest ancient human art remains found in the world so far.
Professor Zhang Dian has long been engaged in research and teaching on geomorphology and natural environment. His research fields cover earth science, geography, environmental science, archaeology and humanities, and he is a professor selected by the National Major Talent Project, a special professor of Guangzhou University’s “Hundred Talents Program”, an honorary professor of the University of Hong Kong, and an honorary researcher of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
A “serendipitous” discovery spanning 30 years
The hand and footprints of Qiushan Hot Springs have been a part of local history for a long time, since 1988, when Zhang Dian was doing his PhD thesis on the karst landscapes of the Tibetan Plateau at the School of Geography, University of Manchester, UK. As he needed to do field research, Zhang Dian came to Qiusang Hot Spring in Qiusang Village, Dulong Deqing District, Lhasa, at an altitude of 4,268 meters. While walking around after completing water measurement, temperature measurement, and chemical sampling, Zhang Dian saw a row of hand and footprints on a large deposit of calcium carbonate spring water (a chemical precipitate formed by geothermal water and steam containing minerals and mineral salts in rock fissures and on the surface) nearby. It was already afternoon and they were very clear in the setting sun.
Zhang Dian found it very interesting, because when the underground hot springs gushed out of the ground, the original bicarbonate ions dissolved in the water will be a large number of precipitation of calcium carbonate soft mud, these soft mud when new is very soft, can provide the creation of hand and footprints “drawing board”, over time will gradually harden. Therefore, these hand and footprints should be left a long time ago, not made now.
Qiusang means “good water” in Tibetan, and this natural hot spring on the half-slope has always been a place for local Tibetans to bathe and heal, with only a pool and a stone house at that time. After 10 years, Zhang Dian went to Tibet again in 1998. He was teaching in the Department of Geography at the University of Hong Kong and started to study the peculiarities of the large geomorphology of the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau again, and returned to Qiusang Hot Spring one day to see the strange row of hand and footprints again.
Zhang Dian did not study archaeology, but nowadays archaeology is the biggest cross-discipline, and all disciplines have a use in archaeology. In 2002, the results were published in a professional journal, followed by a review article in Nature, which was very sensational.
20,000 years ago, the Earth’s climate was still in the Quaternary Ice Age, and in the understanding of the Western academic community at that time, Tibet should have been covered by a whole big ice cap like Greenland, with thin air and barren earth, which would not be a happy place for human life, and how could there be human hand and footprints? Therefore, the paper at that time rejected the theory of a large ice cap during the last ice age of the Tibetan Plateau and advanced the earliest time of long-term or seasonal occupation of the cold, oxygen-poor plateau by 15,000 years, because the most important archaeological site in Tibet at that time – the Tibetan Late Neolithic Karo site in Chamdo – was -was dated to 5,000-4,000 years ago, which means that there was no history of human activity in Tibet before then.
At that time, Zhang Dian thought it was a surprise to reveal that ancient humans had been active on the Tibetan plateau for 20,000 years, but he did not expect that the 10 ancient human hand and footprints found later would provide earlier evidence of the earliest time of long-term or seasonal occupation of the plateau by ancient humans.
At the end of 2017, Zhang Dian resigned from the University of Hong Kong to teach at the School of Geographical Sciences and Remote Sensing, Guangzhou University. 2018, as a visiting researcher at the Institute of Tibetan Plateau, Chinese Academy of Sciences, he participated in the second comprehensive scientific expedition to the Tibetan Plateau, and went back to Qiusang Hot Spring with his CAS partner Academician Chen Fahu’s team, where several new hand and footprints were found on a rock a dozen meters from the initial discovery point. That summer, when Zhang Dian and members of the Guangzhou University team went up to the plateau to continue the expedition, people from the village committee said that there were other hand and footprints in the area.
This time, the newly discovered hand and footprints were 1.2 kilometers in a straight line from the original site, adjacent to the Xiongqu River, at an altitude of 4,062 meters, and consisted of five handprints and five footprints that were intentionally pressed, with the hand and footprints arranged in an orderly fashion to form an image. The rock layer at the bottom of the hillside where these 10 hand and footprints are located is much older, certainly more than the upper 20,000 years. In 2021, the research results were published in Science Bulletin (English version), and later selected by Archaeology magazine as one of the “Top Ten Discoveries in World Archaeology” in 2021. The second place was chosen by Archaeology magazine as one of the “Top Ten World Archaeological Discoveries” in 2021.
The world’s earliest known rock face art
So how do researchers determine whether these hand and footprints were pressed or carved by ancient humans at a later stage? And how do you prove that ancient humans used hand and footprints for conscious creation?
Identifying whether the hand and footprints were created by ancient humans on soft clay is the key to the study, said Zhang Dian. The second author of the paper, a well-known British lineage scientist, did a quantitative analysis through 3D scanning, modeling and anatomical statistics of human hand and footprints. It can be seen that these found hand and footprints are generally consistent with the reference anatomy of modern human hand and footprints; there are “ridges” formed between the edges of the hand and footprints and the fingers and toes due to the compression of the soft mud, and these ridges are significantly higher than the adjacent surface of Quanhua, a phenomenon that is impossible to occur on hard rock surfaces; and there is a clear Pressing order, this order is based on the extrusion deformation of adjacent prints to determine, but also only in the soft mud.
In addition, the smooth surface formed by the palms of the hands (feet) after pressing contrasts with the rough surface of the surface of Quanhua around the slab; there are no traces of knocking, artificial abrasion, or other stone carving tools on the surface of the hands and feet and the surrounding rocks, all of which negate the possibility of carving with tools. It is also interesting to note that the fingers of these handprints are relatively long, a phenomenon that sometimes occurs in sparsely populated areas.
Analysis of the morphology and composition reveals some “conscious” phenomena: the images formed by the impressions are spatially ordered, with the fingers and toes pointing in the same direction; the uniform force keeps the morphology of all the hands and feet intact; the footprint number ZWF23 clearly indicates an intentional and precise overlap of the footprints, the rotation of the fingers of ZWH3 and ZWF24 heel with intentional force; the degree of finger spread was adjusted to the size of the space, and ZWH1 and ZWH14 intentionally increased the degree of spread. By the behavioral traces of these hand and footprints being kept at a distance and avoiding crossover as much as possible, you can imagine the process of ancient humans from the selection of the right hand and foot, to the positioning of the creative prototype into the available space, and the well-thought-out design of the overall composition of the print in advance.
In this dating, the researchers considered various methods, and the isotope laboratory of Xi’an Jiaotong University, using the currently advanced uranium system measurements, determined that the surface of this “artistic rock slab” is dated between 226,000 and 169,000 years ago, and belongs to the third stage of Quanhua deposition. Among them, the direct age of the ridge formed by extrusion between two fingerprints, number ZWH15, is 207,000-188,000 years old. Since the ridge is only 1 cm thick, Zhang Dian prefers to recognize 207,000 to 188,000 years as a more accurate age for the rock face art, because the time of hand and footprint formation is equal to the time of Quanghua deposition.
The creation of ancient human hand and footprints was done when the calcium carbonate spring wars were in plastic form, so in 2019, Zhang Dian also did an experiment on modern hot spring soft mud deposited handprints. He pressed vertically in the area below Qiusang hot spring where seepage is active or where the stream contains soft calcium watts, leaving three handprints, and when he visited again in 2020, he found that one had formed a lithified handprint and the other two had been washed away. The process of calcium carbonate mud lithogenesis is unidirectional and rapid; as soon as it is dehydrated, it sets as quickly as cement, and once it is lithogenic it is no longer possible to soften.
So, why is the image of the five handprints and five footprints in the ruins an artistic expression of ancient man?
Due to the lack of prehistoric writing, rock face art is often considered an expression of ancient human thought. Handprints and intentionally created footprints are one of the early forms of artistic expression of ancient humans, and are referred to as works of art in academic works in archaeology, cognitive science, psychology and art history. For example, there is abstract reticulated petroglyph art on conglomerate in Blombos Cave in South Africa, 73,000 years old; some are realized by means of carving, such as ostrich eggshell carvings in caves in South Africa, about 60,000 years old. Of course, there are also very creative ways, such as placing the palm of the hand on the rock wall and blowing paint on it to get a handprint outline, etc.
These five handprints and five footprints combined into a rock slab in Qiusang village, Tibet, are considered as art because it is an imitation of ancient human impressions of their limbs, and there is an intentional act of pressing to make them and the way the patterns are combined.
The level of cognition of ancient humans 200,000 years ago
The emergence of art is a milestone in human evolution, and even a few deliberate handprints mean that such an act has surpassed all actions that had to be completed just to survive. Moreover, it is older than all known rock face art in the world today.
How does rockface art compare to paleolithic manufacturing and the use of fire, which were unique milestones in the evolution of human cognition in ancient man?
According to Zhang Dian, rock art is a visual representation of what ancient humans imagined and wanted to express through materialized images. In terms of image perception and thought patterns, it may be more sophisticated than the creation of paleolithic. five handprints and five footprints, presumably left by two children from the size. Imagining the scene, it is likely that there were adults soaking in a hot spring nearby while two children played in the soft mud, leaving these hand and footprints.
If one compares the thought patterns and visual perception abilities displayed by the creators of Qiushan’s hand and footprints during the creation process with the cognitive development process of modern humans, manipulating symbols and images related to specific objects is the behavior of modern human children at the age of 7 to 12 years of cognitive development. That is, if the anatomically estimated age of the creators of the hand and footprints is accurate, their cognitive abilities in terms of images are the same as those of their modern counterparts. This artistic rock slab records what perceptual psychology calls the “ecological self” in the form of traces.
However, although ancient humans were anatomically similar to modern humans, whether their minds were on the same level as modern humans remains to be supported by other evidence.
So, what kind of person left these hand and footprints here? Anatomy proves that the ancient humans that appeared on the Tibetan plateau between 207,000 and 188,000 years ago were not modern humans Homo sapiens, not our ancestors, because modern humans came out of Africa only 70,000 years ago. 5 handprints and 5 footprints are dated earlier than all Homo sapiens remains found so far in Eurasia, but are very close to the fossil age of Denisovans recently found at a slightly lower altitude on the Tibetan plateau (160,000 years ago). million years ago) is very close. Therefore, the possibility of Denisovans or other ancient human species at high altitudes on the Tibetan Plateau cannot be ruled out.
The mainstream view has been that the key to the disappearance of other ancient human species such as Nyandertes and Denisovans is that their cognitive abilities differ from those of modern humans and that art is the preserve of Homo sapiens. But the artistic cognition of the creators of the 10 hand and footprints in Qiusang, Tibet, is no different from that of modern humans of the same age.
Cognitive science is a landmark emerging research discipline in the world of science in the 20th century, and it has attracted widespread attention from scientists worldwide as a cutting-edge discipline that explores the working mechanisms of the human brain or mind. The hand models and handprints found everywhere in rock art around the globe reflect the necessary role of the hand in human evolution. Zhang Dian is writing a paper on the importance of studying hand and footprint art from the perspective of cognitive science, by examining the evolutionary patterns of human cognitive abilities and prehistoric artistic creations of the time.
Conservation of Qiushan’s hand and footprints is urgent
Qiusang Hot Springs is now a tourist resort that combines bathing, tourism and leisure, so how has the geography and footprints of Qiusang changed over the past 30 years?
Qiusang Hot Spring is located halfway up a mountain slope, and in the earliest days you had to climb up a vertical distance of more than 200 meters to reach it. The entire limestone landscape covers an area of about 0.7 square kilometers and is dotted with many ancient springs, modern springs, and the remains of ancient buildings from hundreds of years ago. Nowadays, the amount of water in Qiusang Hot Spring is very little, and only flows along the small ditch, and the coverage of the spring watts by the hot spring is much smaller. Quanhua is a precipitation crystallization of calcium carbonate, and the rock formed is limestone, and layers of it peel off easily.
On January 7, 2022, Zhang Dian went to Qiusang Hot Spring again, this time to continue to do research work such as geological profiles and spring sampling, while calling on the community to protect these ancient human hand and footprints. Before leaving, Zhang Dian communicated with the State Administration of Cultural Heritage, hoping that the archaeological findings at Qiusang would be actively and strongly protected. In the days following his arrival, after communication, he also reached a unified understanding with the regional cultural heritage bureaus at all levels and the local Qiusang village. Qiusang village attached great importance to conservation and suggested the implementation of protection measures while developing tourism, such as first covering the ancient hand and footprints with a glass cover.

Comments are closed